2023 Madisen Wallace
2022 Bradie Jill Jones
2020 Kassaddee Jo Jones
2019 McKaylie Richins
2018 Carly Peercy
2017 McKenna Hales Richins
2016 Cassidy Black Richins
2015 Bailey Jo Woosley Holmes
2014 Brandy Mortensen
2013 MaKenzie Maughan Hart
2012 Chenae Shiner Vest
2011 Jamie Udell
2010 Martina Wardle Larsen
2009 Chris Andrea Wade Price
2008 Renae Cowley
2007 Jenna Witaker Hirschi
2006 Cami Cushing McBride
2005 Kristan Jo Gibbs Earl

2004 Kaydee Nelson
2003 Angi Prevedel Kellett
2002 Ashley Kendell Redd
2001 Jamie Casper Slagowski
2000 Amber Webb Turner
1999 Angie Burton
1998 Bobbie Sage Allred Burns
1997 Mary Shaw
1996 Kaycee Allred Wolfey
1995 Tanya McKinnon Bartlett
1994 Emilee Lott Woosley
1993 Jennifer Hawkes Flint
1992  Shannon Conley Mullins
1991 Nicole Maughan Cypers
1990  Lori Jo Evans Wilcox
1989  Kristy Hughes
1988 Changel LaRoque Taylor
1987 JaNae Barlow Francis

1986  Tauna Blair Nichols
1985  Vicki Vest Woodward
1984  Ragan Brown Hall
1983  Janice Nelson
1982  Joan Thompson Robinson
1981  Gena Blonquist Black
1980  Diane Hooper Prescott
1979  Desiree Cooper Larsen
1978  Tammy Taylor Mitchell
1977  Diane Hamilton
1976  Kristen Allred Williams
1975  Karin Allred Rosser
1974  Connie Della Lucia Robinson
1973  Sherrie Dawn Ross Hunting
1972  Geri Dawn Gibson Allred
1971  Sue Merrill Agricola
1970  Sharon Sinsel
1969  Ann Parker Judd

1968  Julie Ward Facer
1967  Sandra Staheli Turnbeaugh
1966  Susie Bauter Adams
1965  Linda Rogers
1964  Shari Starbuck Cunningham
1963  Jeri Snow
1962  Mary Ann Reber
1961  Carma Jean Staheli
1960  No Pageant was held
1959  Judy McMullin
1958  Shirley Hodsen Frost
1957  Connie Jones DeSimon
1956  Renee Mueller
1955  Karen NeuenSchwander Gall